Imagine this. It’s Tuesday afternoon, and sunlight gently filters through your office window.

You glance at the clock. It’s time for your feedback meeting with a team member who is talented but incredibly sensitive.

Your stomach tightens slightly at the thought of this conversation.

You’ve been here before, and you know how quickly it can derail if not handled carefully.

I’ve seen this scenario unfold countless times in my work as a leadership coach – talented leaders unintentionally bruising the confidence of their sensitive but valuable team members.

It doesn’t have to be this way.

Let me walk you through a better approach.

1. Start with Empathy (Set the Stage)

Picture sitting comfortably across from your team member. You smile warmly, setting a reassuring tone.

Say something like:

“I’ve noticed how dedicated you’ve been lately. Your passion really shines through in your work, and it makes a big difference.”

A simple sentence can lower defenses, soften tension, and show that you genuinely care.

2. Get Specific (Clarify the Situation)

Now gently shift to specifics. Vague comments can heighten anxiety. Clear observations offer stability.

Say something like:

“During yesterday’s meeting, I noticed you held back a bit, especially when discussing timelines. I value your perspective immensely – what kept you from sharing?”

Notice how you’ve clearly described what you saw, without judgment.

3. Use “I” Statements (Avoiding Defensiveness)

By framing feedback from your perspective, you avoid blame and open the door for understanding.

Say something like:

“I sensed that you felt unsure about the project timeline. Did I read that right?”

You’re giving space for dialogue, inviting them to share their perspective.

4. Balance Feedback with Affirmation (Building Confidence)

Always weave in positive reinforcement. It anchors trust and helps your feedback land softly.

Say something like:

“You have exceptional attention to detail. If we can apply that strength to the timelines too, imagine how smoothly things would go.”

This subtle reframing can transform tension into optimism.

5. Invite Dialogue (Encourage Openness)

Feedback is a two-way street. Allowing them to express their thoughts shows respect.

Say something like:

“That’s my perspective – but I’m genuinely curious. How do you feel about this?”

Feel the shift in energy. You’ve invited them to be a collaborator in their own growth.

6. Focus on the Future (Offer Support and Solutions)

Rather than dwelling on past mistakes, focus together on future possibilities. You’re creating a path forward.

Say something like:

“How can we approach this differently next time? What would help you feel more confident sharing openly?”

Picture your team member relaxing, engaging, feeling heard and valued.

7. Follow Up (Reinforce Progress)

The conversation doesn’t end when they leave your office. Regular, encouraging check-ins help the team member see their own growth.

Say something like:

“I’ve noticed you’re speaking up more often lately. It’s fantastic to see your confidence grow.”

The Bottom Line

Great leaders know feedback isn’t about correction – it’s about fostering growth.

With empathy, clarity, and collaborative dialogue, you turn potentially uncomfortable conversations into empowering experiences.

As you reflect, imagine how much stronger your team would be if feedback always felt supportive.

It’s achievable. And now, you have the roadmap to do it well.

Florin

PS: Want to receive these leadership insights directly into your inbox?

Subscribe here: https://florinlungu.com/lftn-subscribe/